1. News & Issues

Discuss in my forum

Weiss on Pay Raises: Federal Government or Feudal Government?

From Justin Quinn, About.com GuideSeptember 29, 2009

Follow me on:

These days, Americans like to believe they're much better off than the English ancestors of their Founding Fathers -- ancestors who were entrenched in a feudal system that prevented the upward social stratification of those on its lower end.

Believe it or not, Present-day America bears some startling similarities to those bygone days. Take a look:

In the English feudal system, a pyramid of power dictated life's terms almost universally.

People could move up and down the ladder of the feudal system through hard work (or the lack thereof), but serfs couldn't become kings under normal circumstances, and kings couldn't become serfs under any circumstances (a king might lose his head every now and then, but suffer the indignity of serfdom? Never!).

Finally, the Medieval feudal system relied on members of all castes displaying open allegiance to their superiors.

For those fortunate enough to have jobs, this may sound like a day at the office!

Let's be clear: America is a great place to live, and there are more opportunities in this country and more changes for success here than any other place in the world. And if it differers from Medieval England in any respect, it's that anyone can become president if he (or she!) works hard enough and is intelligent enough in the minds of his (or her!) fellow Americans. Our current president testifies amply to this point.

But while America is the best system of government Mankind has yet to produce, it is by no means perfect, and there are eerie similarities between modern-day America and Medieval England. One need look no further than the Congressional "cost of living allowance" built into the annual federal budget for proof. This underhanded mechanism casts a protective bubble over politicians by boosting their pay regardless of their performance without the bothersome attention of the public creating a stir. Thus, this small body of ruling class citizens perpetuates its social superiority and its financial predominance in perpetuity.

About.com's raging moderate, guest writer William Weiss, examines this practice in relation to the debilitating recession and the overall US economy.

From the article:

We live in a system of government that taxes the individual into poverty, then takes the tax money and re-distributes it to our “lords” -- those who operate the federal government. Peasants faced a similar struggle during the years of the early English feudal system. Your bad year was not the concern of your “lord.” The lord was paid either way.

Join Me on Facebook | Get My Twitter Updates

Photo © Don Bishop/Photodisc/Getty Images

Comments

September 29, 2009 at 10:46 am
(1) RealTime53 says:

“These sacrifices would allow members of individual households to keep more of the money they earn, and for once, taxpayers would feel like they have real representation.”

Really? This guy is complaining that Congressmen earn 3.5 times the median family income and are getting a $4,700 raise. How much additional money does this ‘moderate’ believe that the individual household would realize through these sacrifices? What percentage of a penny?

And yet, somehow this is comparable to the feudal system? This is hyperbole, pure and simple.

September 29, 2009 at 3:43 pm
(2) RealTime53 says:

Well, let’s see if I can answer my own question. If Congress drops the COLA, that’s:

$5000 times 535 representatives equals about $2.7M. Divide that by 350,000 million Americans ….. the average American will see about 76 cents.

I was wrong. It wasn’t a fraction of a penny.

Darn those COLAs. You can’t buy a cola with my fraction of one. This is an issue. Just not a real large one.

September 30, 2009 at 6:53 pm
(3) J says:

Saturn employees got a 100% PAY CUT today. They created wealth. Teachers, police, fire, judges, state workers, etc. create nothing and their pay is riciulously high. Don’t listen to me or them, PRIVATIZE and allow the free market to set pay and prices. Check the U.S. Constitution which is distinctly NOT the Communist Manifesto. We don’t want Michael Stealing a job from an American; we don’t want Michael Steal’s affirmative action. We don’t want WARS FOR JEWS anymore. Stop the foreign adventures and DEPORT the foreign INVADERS – if you’re not an American, go home; hey, Vietnamese parasite refugees – California is not your refugee camp, go home. Get the foreigners out and get Americans out of foreign lands. Stop coddling Chinese communists and make Americans free; free of this or any tyrannical government. The dictatorship of the proliteriat is oppresive to say the least. The American judiciary and military have ignore their fiduciary duties and the country must be taken back so that Americans can pursue happiness not be enslaved by the state. FREEDOM. That’s America. NOT FREE STUFF. FREE-DOM!! We don’t need civil discourse, we need civil war!!!

Leave a Comment


Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>

©2013 About.com. All rights reserved.